Why Friendly Fraud Is Hard to Prove
The sale was real, so the merchant must build a case from clues. Here is what counts as proof and what to do with it.
Friendly fraud is hard to prove because the sale itself was real. The cardholder, or someone close to them, made the purchase. There is no forged card and no stolen number to point to. The merchant must build a case from clues instead. The clues must show the cardholder approved the sale or got something from it. Even then, the issuer may not agree.
What is friendly fraud and why is it hard to prove?
In a card-absent fraud dispute, the cardholder says they did not authorize or take part in an online, mail or phone sale. With friendly fraud, that claim is false. The cardholder did take part, or someone in their home did.
That is what makes it hard. The merchant is not proving a theft. The merchant is proving the cardholder's own behavior. The proof is indirect. It is things like delivery records, device data, past purchases and emails. None of it is a signed confession. An issuer can look at the same facts and still side with the cardholder.
Types of friendly fraud
Friendly fraud comes in three common forms.
- Intentional. The cardholder bought the goods, used them, and still disputed the charge to get money back.
- Accidental. The cardholder forgot the purchase. Or they did not know the name on their statement. Or they expected a refund that never came.
- Family fraud. A spouse, child or other household member made the purchase without the cardholder knowing.
Accidental and family cases are often honest mistakes. No one meant to cheat. See what a friendly fraud chargeback is for more on how these disputes work.
Evidence that can help prove friendly fraud
Compelling evidence is proof that the cardholder took part in the sale, received the goods or benefited from the sale. It does not force the issuer to decide in your favor, but it is the strongest case you can make. Useful items include:
- Photos or emails showing the cardholder has or uses the goods.
- Proof that a member of the cardholder's household or family made the purchase.
- Earlier payments for the same goods or service that were never disputed.
- Evidence that the same device and card were used in an earlier undisputed sale.
- For a subscription, show a binding contract. Show proof the cardholder uses the service. And show an earlier payment that was never disputed.
- For a card-absent fraud dispute, show earlier purchases that were never disputed. They should share data like device ID or IP address.
The pattern matters more than any single item. A card used before, on the same device, for the same kind of goods, tells a story a lone receipt cannot.
Compelling Evidence 3.0
Compelling Evidence 3.0 lets your acquirer fix the dispute. The cardholder cannot argue with the fix later. It only applies to card-absent sales where the cardholder says they did not authorize or take part. It works for recurring transactions too.
It is not available for a first time buyer, who has no purchase history to compare. If you do not meet the remedy criteria, you can still use the other compelling evidence types.
Pre-dispute tools: Order Insight, CDRN and RDR
The best dispute is the one that never starts. Verifi's tools give the cardholder a credit before the chargeback starts.
Order Insight gives issuer call centers the full details of each order. It clears up customer confusion and heads off disputes. Disputes are rejected when you send the required data through Order Insight before the dispute starts.
Rapid Dispute Resolution (RDR) settles pre-disputes for you. A decision engine follows rules you set. Your rules decide which dispute inquiries you take on and which you turn down. Resolved inquiries do not count toward your sale to dispute ratio. With the RDR Decision API, you can write your own logic for which cases to accept.
CDRN is Verifi's older tool. You choose to give the cardholder a credit. That settles a Visa or non-Visa dispute before a chargeback is filed. Disputes resolved with CDRN or RDR cannot be disputed again later.
Verifi reaches issuers on Visa and on other networks, including Mastercard, Discover and American Express. See chargeback prevention tools for a wider view.
Prevention beats proof
The cheapest case is the one you never have to build.
- Clear billing descriptors. An unclear name on a card statement can make a cardholder believe a real charge is fraud. Check that your acquirer has the right business name, city and state.
- Clear policies. Your website must show its refund policy before final checkout, with a click to accept button or checkbox. For phone orders, you must be able to prove the cardholder received and acknowledged your policy.
- 3-D Secure. It adds a check of the buyer's identity before an online purchase is authorized. Low risk purchases are authenticated in the background. For a riskier purchase, the issuer may ask for a one time password or a biometric check. A passed check can move the loss off the merchant.
- Fast service. If an order will be late, tell the customer in writing and let them cancel. When a customer cancels a recurring charge, cancel it right away.
For more steps, see how to prevent friendly fraud.
The challenge and the path forward
Friendly fraud is hard to prove because you are arguing against the person who holds the card. You cannot change that. You can gather proof of past authorized use. You can use pre-dispute tools to settle claims before they become chargebacks. And you can stop the honest mistakes that start many of these disputes. Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem and fix.
Sources
- Dispute Management Guidelines for Visa Merchants June 2024
- Evolution of Compelling Evidence – Client FAQs
- Stop Chargebacks & Fraud | Verifi Order Insight for Merchants
- Resolve Pre-Disputes Automatically | CDRN and RDR for Sellers | Verifi
- Visa Secure EMV 3-D Secure for Merchants | Visa
- 3D Secure: your guide to safer transactions | Visa