Chargeback Fraud: What It Is and How to Stop It
A merchant's guide to chargeback fraud, how it differs from friendly fraud, and the network programs that punish it.
Chargeback fraud is a false chargeback. A customer makes a purchase, receives the goods or uses the service, then tells their bank the charge was not authorized. The merchant loses the sale and pays a chargeback fee on top.
What is chargeback fraud?
In chargeback fraud, the cardholder knows they made the purchase. They dispute it anyway to get their money back and keep what they bought. This is sometimes called a chargeback scam or a fraudulent chargeback.
The dispute arrives as a card-absent fraud claim. The cardholder says they did not authorize or take part in an online, mail or phone sale. Sometimes that is true. When it is false, and the cardholder made the purchase and took the goods, it is chargeback fraud.
Chargeback fraud vs. friendly fraud: key differences
Friendly fraud covers disputes where a cardholder disputes a charge without bad intent. A family member may have made the purchase. The cardholder may not have known the name on their statement. Or they forgot a subscription renewal. The cardholder is confused, not cheating.
Chargeback fraud is done on purpose. The cardholder knows the sale was real and disputes it anyway. The line between them is intent, and a merchant often cannot tell them apart from the outside. Both cost the same in fees and lost revenue, and both count toward the same network ratios. For a closer look at the no-intent kind, see friendly fraud chargebacks.
How chargeback fraud hurts your business
A fraudulent chargeback costs you the sale, the goods you shipped and a chargeback fee. The fee is paid win or lose. Time spent gathering evidence and answering disputes is a cost too, and so is the staff time spent on it.
The bigger danger is what high dispute levels do to your standing with the card networks. Visa and Mastercard both track fraud and disputes at the merchant level. Go over their limits and your acquirer must put you in a monitoring program. That can mean monthly fees and required fixes. Your processing costs can rise, and in serious cases an acquirer may close your account. Losing card processing ends most online businesses. For more detail, see how chargebacks hurt your business.
The role of card network programs: VAMP and the Excessive Chargeback Program
Both networks run programs that punish merchants with too many fraud claims and disputes. Visa's program is the Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program, or VAMP. Mastercard's is the Excessive Chargeback Program, or ECP.
VAMP brought several older fraud and dispute programs together into one program for acquirers. Each month, Visa checks fraud, dispute and enumeration levels. It then names the acquirers or merchants that go over its monthly thresholds. The VAMP ratio adds the count of fraud and disputes, then divides by the count of settled card-not-present transactions. Merchants that Visa names must put fraud controls in place.
Mastercard built the ECP so each acquirer watches chargebacks for each merchant. A merchant that goes over the thresholds becomes an Excessive Chargeback Merchant, or ECM. A higher level is called a High Excessive Chargeback Merchant, or HECM. Acquirers must monitor these merchants and may be assessed for not complying. A merchant that stays over the limits can be listed in the MATCH Pro system, which makes it hard to open a new merchant account.
The networks change these thresholds and fees in phases, so ask your acquirer for the current figures.
How pre-dispute tools help stop chargeback fraud
You do not have to wait for a chargeback to land. Alert services warn you while the cardholder is still talking to their bank, before a formal dispute opens. That gives you time to refund and stop the chargeback from being filed.
Ethoca Alerts connects issuers and merchants so they can share fraud and dispute data. When a cardholder reports a charge to their issuer, the issuer may send an alert through the Ethoca network. Ethoca was acquired by Mastercard. You can review the sale, stop fulfillment or issue a refund before the dispute starts. See what to do when an Ethoca alert arrives.
Verifi runs several tools. Order Insight gives issuer call centers detailed order information to clear up customer confusion and head off disputes. Disputes are rejected when a merchant sends the required data through Order Insight before the dispute starts. Rapid Dispute Resolution, or RDR, settles pre-disputes on its own. It follows rules the seller sets. The Cardholder Dispute Resolution Network, or CDRN, lets the merchant credit the cardholder. This settles the dispute before a chargeback is filed. Disputes resolved with CDRN or RDR cannot be disputed again later. Disputes resolved before a chargeback starts do not count against Visa's dispute ratio.
Prevention best practices
The best defense is to prevent the dispute in the first place.
- Make sure your name is clear on card statements. An unclear name can make a cardholder believe a real charge is fraud.
- Show your refund policy before final checkout, with a click to accept button or checkbox. For phone orders, be able to prove the cardholder received and acknowledged your policy.
- Get proof of delivery or pickup so you can answer a dispute where the customer says the goods never came.
- Use 3-D Secure, such as Visa Secure. It checks the buyer's identity before an online purchase goes through. Merchants that use it are protected from certain fraud disputes when they process the sale the right way.
- Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem and fix.
For the no-intent kind of dispute, many of the same steps apply. See how to prevent friendly fraud.
Sources
- ethoca.com
- developer.mastercard.com
- Introducing the Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program | Visa
- VAMP_external fact sheet_2025 v2
- Security Rules and Procedures
- Dispute Management Guidelines for Visa Merchants June 2024
- Evolution of Compelling Evidence – Client FAQs
- Stop Chargebacks & Fraud | Verifi Order Insight for Merchants
- Resolve Pre-Disputes Automatically | CDRN and RDR for Sellers | Verifi
- Visa Secure EMV 3-D Secure for Merchants | Visa
- 3D Secure: your guide to safer transactions | Visa