ChargebackPlaybook Contents

Friendly fraud

Friendly fraud chargebacks and how to stop them

A friendly fraud chargeback comes from a real customer, not a stolen card. Here is why it happens and how to prevent it.

A friendly fraud chargeback is a dispute filed by the cardholder. That person made the purchase. It is not true fraud, where a thief uses a stolen card. The customer knows the sale. They still ask their bank to take the money back.

What is a friendly fraud chargeback?

In true fraud, someone other than the cardholder makes the purchase. In friendly fraud, the real cardholder makes the purchase and then disputes it anyway. Sometimes they do it on purpose to get goods for free. Often it is an honest mistake. The customer may not know the charge. Or they forgot about a subscription.

Either way, the merchant pays. The sale was real, but the dispute still costs you fees, lost goods and time.

Why do cardholders file friendly fraud disputes?

Most friendly fraud starts with confusion, not bad intent.

  • The customer does not recognize the charge on their statement.
  • They forgot about a purchase made by a family member.
  • They did not read your refund or cancellation policy.
  • The goods arrived late, or never arrived, and they disputed instead of calling you.
  • They meant to cancel a subscription but did not know how.

Some customers dispute on purpose to keep the goods and the money. That is chargeback abuse. Most friendly fraud, though, comes from avoidable mistakes in how a merchant runs the sale.

How friendly fraud hurts your business

Every chargeback costs you the sale amount. You also lose the goods you shipped and pay a dispute fee. Win or lose, you spend staff time gathering evidence. Too many disputes can push you into a monitoring program. That brings extra fees and paperwork. See how chargebacks hurt your business for the full picture.

Prevention: Clear billing descriptors

Cardholders must be able to recognize your charges when they look at their bank statements. An unclear or confusing merchant name can make a cardholder believe a real charge is fraud.

Check that your acquirer has the right business name, city and state for your account. You can check your name by buying something at each of your outlets and reading your own card statement. If the name is not the one customers know, ask your acquirer to fix it. See make your name clear on card statements for more.

Prevention: Clear policies and communication

Clearly sharing your return, refund and cancellation policies can help you avoid misunderstandings and disputes. The cardholder must see your policy at the time of purchase.

  • Your website must show its refund policy before final checkout, with a click to accept button or checkbox.
  • For phone orders, you must be able to prove the cardholder received and acknowledged your policy.
  • If your store takes no returns, the words no returns must be on all copies of the receipt.

Make sure your product descriptions in ads, online, on receipts and in phone scripts are accurate and not misleading. Never send an unhappy customer to the manufacturer instead of trying to fix the problem yourself. If a customer with a valid complaint contacts you, act promptly and issue a credit as appropriate.

Prevention: Fulfillment and delivery best practices

If an order will be late, tell the customer in writing and let them cancel if they choose. For online and phone sales, do not deposit the sale until you have shipped the goods. A customer who sees a charge before the goods arrive may contact their card issuer to dispute it.

Proof of delivery or pickup lets you answer a dispute where the customer says the goods never came. Keep tracking numbers. Keep signatures and pickup records too.

Prevention: Subscription and recurring billing care

Recurring charges draw a lot of disputes. When a customer cancels a recurring charge, cancel it right away or as the customer asks. Tell the customer in writing that their subscription is cancelled and when the cancellation takes effect.

Train your sales and service staff to handle recurring charges. Send reminders before each renewal. Then the charge is never a surprise.

Prevention: Fraud tools

Always get an authorization for mail order, phone, internet and recurring sales, whatever the amount. For online and phone sales, use tools like Visa Secure, CVV2 and the Address Verification Service to help reduce fraud.

3-D Secure adds a check of the buyer's identity before an online purchase is authorized. Visa Secure is Visa's global EMV 3-D Secure program. Merchants that use Visa Secure are protected from certain fraud disputes, as long as the sale is processed correctly. Authentication proves who the cardholder is. That stops many false claims that the buyer was not the real account owner.

Prevention: Pre-dispute tools

Pre-dispute tools warn you before a chargeback is filed, so you can refund and close the matter.

Ethoca Alerts connects issuers and merchants so they can share fraud and dispute data. When a cardholder reports a charge to their issuer, the issuer may send an alert through the Ethoca network. After an alert, a merchant can review the sale, stop fulfillment, or issue a refund before a formal dispute. See what to do when an Ethoca alert arrives.

Rapid Dispute Resolution resolves pre-disputes automatically, using a decision engine run by rules the seller sets. The seller's rules decide which dispute inquiries it accepts liability for and which it declines. Dispute inquiries resolved at this pre-dispute stage do not count toward the seller's sale to dispute ratio.

Verifi's older dispute tool is the Cardholder Dispute Resolution Network, known as CDRN. With CDRN, the merchant chooses to give the cardholder a credit. That settles the dispute before a chargeback is filed. Disputes resolved with CDRN or RDR cannot be disputed again later.

Prevention: Track disputes and find root causes

Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem and fix. A merchant that sells both in person and online should track those disputes separately. Watching dispute rates can help merchants find problem areas and improve how they prevent disputes. Work with your acquirer on a plan that finds the root cause of your disputes and how to fix it.

What to do when friendly fraud happens

When a dispute arrives, gather your evidence. Show the receipt and the tracking. Show the policy the customer accepted. Show any emails between you. If the sale was real and you can prove it, answer the dispute through your acquirer's process.

Then fix the cause. If the customer did not recognize the charge, fix your billing name. If the goods were late, fix your shipping. Each friendly fraud dispute tells you something about your business. Learn from it. Use it.

Sources

More in this play

  1. How to Prevent Chargeback Fraud
  2. Chargeback Fraud: What It Is and How to Stop It
  3. Why Friendly Fraud Is Hard to Prove
  4. How to Prevent Friendly Fraud Chargebacks

The plays

  1. Chargeback prevention
  2. Friendly fraud
  3. Chargeback alerts