How to Build a Chargeback Monitoring Program
A chargeback monitoring program keeps you out of Visa and Mastercard penalty programs. Here is how to build one that works.
A chargeback monitoring program is how you watch your disputes, find their causes, and fix them before the card networks penalize you. Visa and Mastercard both run programs that flag merchants with too many chargebacks. Land in one and your processing costs go up, and your acquirer may be forced to act. A monitoring program of your own keeps you ahead of both.
What a chargeback monitoring program is and why you need one
Your monitoring program has two jobs. The first is to track your disputes as they happen, so you see a problem while it is still small. The second is to find the root cause of each dispute type and fix it, so the same problem stops making new disputes.
Watching dispute rates helps you find problem areas and improve how you prevent disputes. Many disputes come from avoidable mistakes in how you process a sale. A late shipment, a confusing statement name, or a refund policy the customer never saw can all turn a real sale into a chargeback. Without tracking, you never see which of these is hitting you.
If you want to understand the numbers behind this, see what a chargeback rate is and how chargebacks hurt your business.
The penalty programs you must avoid: VAMP and Mastercard ECP
Both networks watch your numbers every month and act when they go over set limits.
Visa: the Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program. VAMP stands for the Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program. It brought several older fraud and dispute programs together into one global program for acquirers. Each month, Visa checks fraud, dispute and enumeration levels, and identifies the acquirers or merchants that go over its monthly thresholds. Enumeration is a rapid, brute force card testing attack done at scale, and VAMP watches it too.
The VAMP ratio adds the count of fraud and disputes on card-not-present transactions, then divides by the count of settled transactions. It covers both domestic and cross-border sales. Some things are left out of the ratio. Disputes resolved through pre-dispute solutions do not count against you. Fraud that qualifies for Compelling Evidence 3.0 is left out as well.
When an acquirer is not flagged at the portfolio level, VAMP Excessive Merchant thresholds apply to its merchants. Those thresholds are not the same in every region. Visa changes the figures in phases, so ask your acquirer for the current thresholds rather than relying on old numbers.
Mastercard: the Excessive Chargeback Program. Mastercard designed the ECP so each acquirer closely watches chargebacks at the merchant level. Mastercard compares a merchant's chargebacks in a calendar month with its Mastercard transactions in the month before. A merchant that goes over the thresholds becomes an Excessive Chargeback Merchant, or at a higher level, a High Excessive Chargeback Merchant.
If your merchant stays over the limits, Mastercard may assess your acquirer or require a formal risk review. It may also advise the acquirer on an action plan to lower your chargebacks. Excessive chargebacks are also one of the reasons a merchant can be listed in the MATCH Pro system. A listing there makes it hard to get a new processing account. Again, the exact thresholds change, so get the current figures from your acquirer.
Key metrics to track in your monitoring program
Track a small set of numbers every month.
- Dispute rate. Visa suggests merchants track dispute activity as a share of sales activity. This is the number the network programs measure you against.
- Channel split. A merchant that sells both in person and online should track those disputes separately. Card-not-present sales draw far more disputes.
- Dispute types. Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem and fix. Fraud codes point at your checkout. "Goods not received" points at your shipping.
- Root causes. For each dispute, record why it happened. A pile of "not recognized" claims points at your statement name. A pile of "cancelled subscription" claims points at your cancellation process.
- Dollar amounts. A few large disputes can hurt more than many small ones. Watch the value, not just the count.
Step by step: building your monitoring program
- Get your data. Your acquirer or processor gives you monthly dispute and sales reports. Ask for them if you do not already receive them.
- Set your review routine. Pick a day each month to review the numbers. Compare this month against last month and against the same month last year.
- Sort every dispute by type and cause. Do not just count them. Read the reason codes and note what went wrong with each sale.
- Work with your acquirer on a plan. Visa advises merchants to work with their acquirer on a plan that finds the root cause of their disputes and how to fix it. Your acquirer sees your numbers the way the networks do.
- Fix the causes you find. Common fixes are below.
- Check the results. After a fix, watch whether that dispute type drops over the next two or three months.
Best practices to keep chargebacks low and stay compliant
The fixes depend on what your disputes show, but these practices prevent the most common causes.
Make your charges recognizable. Cardholders must be able to recognize your charges when they look at their bank statements. An unclear name can make a cardholder believe a real charge is fraud. Check your name by buying something at each of your outlets and reading your own card statement. Also check that your acquirer has the right business name, city and state for your account.
Show your policies before the sale. Clearly sharing your return, refund and cancellation policies helps you avoid misunderstandings. Your website must show its refund policy before final checkout, with a click to accept button or checkbox. If your store takes no returns, the words no returns must be on all copies of the receipt.
Ship before you charge. For online and phone sales, do not deposit the sale until you have shipped the goods. A customer who sees a charge before the goods arrive may contact their card issuer to dispute it. If an order will be late, tell the customer in writing and let them cancel.
Keep proof of delivery. Proof of delivery or pickup lets you answer a dispute where the customer says the goods never came.
Handle cancellations fast. When a customer cancels a recurring charge, cancel it right away or as the customer asks, and tell them in writing when it takes effect. Recurring charges are especially likely to draw disputes, so train your staff to handle them.
Use fraud tools at checkout. Always get an authorization for mail order, phone, internet and recurring sales, whatever the amount. Use tools like Visa Secure, CVV2 and the Address Verification Service to reduce fraud. Merchants that use Visa Secure are protected from certain fraud disputes, as long as the sale is processed correctly. See more in chargeback prevention tools.
Fix complaints yourself. Never send an unhappy customer to the manufacturer. If a customer with a valid complaint contacts you, act promptly and issue a credit as appropriate. A refund costs less than a chargeback.
Tell the truth in your listings. Make sure your product descriptions in ads, online, on receipts and in phone scripts are accurate and not misleading.
A monitoring program is not a one time project. Run it every month, keep the root cause list current, and stay in touch with your acquirer about the current network thresholds. For a broader look at the dispute process, see chargebacks for merchants.