ChargebackPlaybook Contents

Chargeback prevention

How Merchants Can Stop Chargebacks Early

Chargebacks cost merchants sales, fees and time. Here is how the dispute process works and the tools that stop disputes early.

A chargeback is a sale the cardholder's bank takes back. The merchant loses the revenue, pays a fee, and spends time answering the claim. Too many chargebacks can also land a merchant in a card network monitoring program. Those programs bring extra fees and reviews. The thresholds change over time, so ask your acquirer for the current figures. This guide walks through how a chargeback merchant can cut these losses with pre-dispute tools and good habits.

How a chargeback happens

A chargeback starts when a cardholder contacts their issuer about a charge. The issuer opens a dispute and pulls the money back from the merchant. The merchant can then answer with evidence, but the sale is already in dispute.

The best time to deal with a chargeback is before it exists. That is what pre-dispute tools do. They connect issuers and merchants so problems get fixed before a formal dispute opens.

Pre-dispute tools

Ethoca Alerts

Ethoca was acquired by Mastercard. Ethoca Alerts connects issuers and merchants so they can share fraud and dispute data. When a cardholder reports a charge to their issuer, the issuer may send an alert through the Ethoca network. The alert warns you before a chargeback is filed.

A fraud alert means a cardholder reported a charge they think they did not make. A dispute alert means a cardholder contacted their issuer about a charge that might become a chargeback. For a fraud alert, you can cancel or refund the sale and look for other fraud. For a dispute alert, you can check with the customer, share a receipt or tracking, or refund.

You can get alerts by push, by pull, or both. After you review the sale, you send an outcome back to Ethoca. An outcome such as refunded tells the issuer not to raise a chargeback. The first final outcome you submit is the one sent to the issuer, so get it right. See what to do when an Ethoca alert arrives.

Verifi Order Insight

Order Insight gives issuer call centers the details of each order. When a cardholder calls confused about a charge, the issuer can see what was bought, which often clears things up. Disputes are rejected when the merchant sends the required data through Order Insight before the dispute starts.

CDRN and RDR

Verifi's older dispute tool is the Cardholder Dispute Resolution Network, known as CDRN. With CDRN, the merchant chooses to give the cardholder a credit to resolve a dispute before a chargeback is filed.

Rapid Dispute Resolution, or RDR, runs on its own. A decision engine runs on rules the seller sets. The rules decide which disputes the seller will pay for and which it will turn down. Disputes resolved at this pre-dispute stage do not count toward the seller's sale to dispute ratio. With the RDR Decision API, merchants write their own logic to decide which cases to accept. Verifi reaches issuers on Visa and on other networks, including Mastercard, Discover and American Express. Disputes resolved with CDRN or RDR cannot be disputed again later.

Prevention habits that cut disputes

Pre-dispute tools catch problems late in the process. These habits stop problems earlier.

  • Make sure customers recognize your charges. An unclear name on a card statement can make a real sale look like fraud. Check how your name shows on card statements.
  • Show your return and refund policy before checkout, with a click to accept. For phone orders, you must be able to prove the cardholder received and acknowledged your policy.
  • Do not deposit the sale until you have shipped the goods. A customer who sees a charge before the goods arrive may contact their issuer.
  • Keep proof of delivery or pickup so you can answer a claim that the goods never came.
  • Cancel recurring charges right away when a customer asks. Tell them in writing that the charge is cancelled. Recurring charges draw disputes, so train staff to handle them.
  • Keep product descriptions accurate in ads, online, on receipts and in phone scripts.
  • Fix problems yourself. Do not send an unhappy customer to the maker of the product.
  • Always get an authorization for mail order, phone, internet and recurring sales, whatever the amount.

3-D Secure and Visa Secure

3-D Secure adds a check of the buyer's identity before an online purchase is authorized. Visa Secure is Visa's global EMV 3-D Secure program, and it helps prevent card-not-present fraud. Low risk purchases are authenticated in the background with no extra steps for the customer. For a riskier purchase, the issuer may ask for a one time password or a biometric check.

Merchants that use Visa Secure are protected from certain fraud disputes, as long as the sale is processed correctly. When authentication works, the merchant may no longer be liable for the sale. The Visa Secure Services site lists approved vendors. It also lists the documents you need to become compliant.

Compelling evidence

In a card-absent fraud dispute, the cardholder says they did not authorize or take part in an online, mail or phone sale. Compelling evidence is proof that they did. This can include photos or emails showing the cardholder has or uses the goods. It can include earlier payments for the same goods or service that were never disputed. It can also show the same device and card were used in an earlier sale that was not disputed. For a subscription, show a binding contract. Show that the cardholder uses the service. Show an earlier payment that was never disputed.

Compelling evidence does not force the issuer to decide in your favor. Compelling Evidence 3.0 lets the acquirer remedy a dispute rather than send evidence the cardholder could dispute further. It only applies to card-absent sales. The cardholder must say they did not authorize or take part. It does not work for a first time buyer, who has no purchase history to compare. A merchant that cannot meet the remedy criteria can still use the other evidence types.

Build a plan

Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem. Work with your acquirer on a plan that finds the root cause of your disputes and how to fix it. Pair that plan with alerts and pre-dispute tools, and most chargebacks never get filed.

Sources

More in this play

  1. How a Chargeback Hurts Your Business
  2. Chargeback Prevention Tools That Cut Disputes
  3. Make Your Business Name Clear on Card Statements

The plays

  1. Chargeback prevention
  2. Friendly fraud
  3. Chargeback alerts