ChargebackPlaybook Contents

Chargeback alerts

How 3DS Fraud Works and How to Stop It

3DS fraud is card-not-present fraud that slips past authentication. Learn how it works, the warning signs, and how to prevent it.

3DS fraud is a type of card-not-present fraud. It happens around 3-D Secure authentication. Fraudsters use stolen card details to buy goods online, and they count on the checkout flow to let them through. 3-D Secure is built to stop this. It checks the buyer's identity before an online purchase is authorized. But it is only a filter. It is a filter, and some bad sales still get through it.

What 3DS fraud is

3-D Secure shares data between the merchant, the card issuer and sometimes the buyer to confirm the real account owner is paying. The merchant starts the authentication request, and the issuer uses an access control server to check the cardholder. Low risk purchases are authenticated in the background, with no extra steps for the customer. For a riskier purchase, the issuer may ask the customer for a one time password or a biometric check.

3DS fraud differs from other card-not-present fraud in one way. The sale carries an authentication mark, so the merchant may believe it is safe. That mark is not a promise. A fraudster can take over an account. Or they can trick the cardholder into sharing a one time password. Either way, they pass the check. The sale looks clean and is not.

How 3DS fraud works

A typical attack runs in steps.

  1. The fraudster gets card details from a breach, a phishing site or a card testing attack.
  2. They place small orders that draw little attention. Small purchases are easy to miss in daily sales.
  3. They exploit the parts of the flow that ask nothing of the buyer. Background checks are easy for customers. They are easy for fraudsters too.
  4. If the goods are digital or sent by email, the fraudster is gone before anyone checks the sale.

Some fraudsters also use bots to test stolen cards at speed. Visa calls this enumeration. It is a rapid, brute force card testing attack done at scale.

Red flags in your transactions

Watch for these signs in your orders.

  • Many small purchases from one device, one IP address or one buyer account in a short time.
  • A shipping address that does not match the billing address. Or many orders to one address from different cards.
  • Sudden bursts of declined authorizations. This can mean someone is testing cards at your checkout.
  • Orders that pass authentication but fail the card security code or address check.
  • New accounts that buy right away, with no browsing history before the purchase.

Track your disputes by type, since each type points to its own business problem and fix. A run of fraud claims on small orders is a sign worth chasing.

How to prevent 3DS fraud

Use the tools built for card-absent sales. For online and phone sales, use tools like Visa Secure, CVV2 and the Address Verification Service to help reduce fraud. Visa Secure is Visa's global EMV 3-D Secure program, and it helps prevent card-not-present fraud. To add this kind of authentication, a merchant connects to a program such as Visa Secure, which sends transaction data to the issuer.

Successful authentication lowers fraud risk and can shift liability away from the merchant. Merchants that use Visa Secure are protected from certain fraud disputes, as long as the sale is processed correctly. That protection is worth having, but do not lean on it alone. Authentication confirms who the cardholder is, while authorization decides if the payment can go ahead. A sale can be authenticated and still be a bad sale.

Add your own checks on top.

  • Set velocity rules that flag many orders from one device, card or address.
  • Hold digital goods for a short review before delivery.
  • Review first time buyers who place large or unusual orders.
  • Watch for card testing and block the source when you find it.

For more tools, see chargeback prevention tools.

What to do when you suspect 3DS fraud

If you spot a bad order before it ships, stop it. Refund the customer to avoid a chargeback. Do not ship goods you believe were bought with a stolen card. Look for other orders from the same device or address.

If the sale already went through and a fraud claim arrives, you may be able to answer it. In a card-absent fraud dispute, the cardholder says they did not authorize or take part in an online, mail or phone sale. Compelling evidence is proof that the cardholder took part in the sale, received the goods or benefited from the sale. Photos or emails showing that the cardholder has or uses the goods can serve as evidence. So can earlier payments for the same goods that were never disputed. So can proof that the same device and card were used in an earlier sale with no dispute.

Know the limits. Compelling evidence does not force the issuer to decide that the cardholder took part in the sale. And if the sale was fraudulent, a refund is cheaper than a lost dispute. For more on that side of the problem, see chargeback fraud and how chargebacks hurt your business.

Staying ahead of 3DS fraud

3-D Secure is a strong tool, and you should use it. But treat its pass mark as one signal, not the whole answer. Pair it with CVV2 and address checks. Add velocity rules. Have a person look at odd orders. Watch your fraud claims each month, and work with your acquirer on a plan that finds the root cause of your disputes. That is how you keep small stolen card purchases from turning into a steady drain on your business.

Sources

More in this play

  1. How Rapid Dispute Resolution Stops Chargebacks
  2. What to Do When an Ethoca Alert Arrives

The plays

  1. Chargeback prevention
  2. Friendly fraud
  3. Chargeback alerts